Water Waste At Its Best

Richard Young, Senior Engineer and Director of Education

bio pic 020208b smaller

I recently spoke at a sustainable food service workshop in Las Vegas that was hosted by Southwest Gas, NV Energy and the Southern Nevada Water Authority. Vegas is one city that cooks a lot of shrimp so, as part of my Operating a Water and Energy Efficient Restaurant presentation, I showed everyone the following video of shrimp thawing in a bowl under running water.

 

Todd Bell, our Senior Energy Analyst sums it up perfectly as “water waste at its best…” While it’s fun to laugh at some of our bad habits, it’s also embarrassing to think that this is standard practice in thousands of kitchens in water challenged areas like Las Vegas and California.

Water is a commodity – it cost money and it’s getting more expensive. Thawing under running water is literally throwing money down the drain. For example: a faucet running at one gallon per minute for one hour a day will send over 20,000 gallons of water down the drain at a cost of around $200.00 (double that cost if you live in California).

Looking at the bigger picture, water is one of the most important ingredients needed to grow food. Farmers are cutting back on crops because they are short on water and meanwhile, kitchens are throwing water away. I wonder how the farmers might feel about that?

So, what is the alternative to thawing in the sink? The best practice is to use a refrigerator. Yes, that requires a bit of planning but it will save you money, you can start today and it’s the right thing to do.

Energy Management Systems and a View into the Smart Restaurants of the Future

Elan Frantz, Research Engineerelan

Disney’s movie “Smart House,” released in 1999, was based on a fictitious, futuristic house with a mind of its own. Upon a command from the owner, the house could whip up a smoothie, clean instantaneously, and even cook dinner. Everyone who has owned or helped operate a restaurant can dream about a “smart restaurant-” a place which can take some of the responsibility of running a foodservice establishment away. While we don’t have kitchens that run themselves yet, we are coming closer to having intelligent restaurants with the emergence of Energy Management Systems (EMS). With an EMS, operators can view the real-time status of the energy-using systems in their restaurant from their computer or smartphone and even control certain aspects like the temperature of the building or the lighting settings. Luckily for restaurant owners, EMS systems do not typically turn evil and trap you like the house in the Disney movie.

Installing an EMS is like adding a central nervous system to your restaurant. Information like restaurant temperature and light settings are all controllable and viewable through a single system. As the name suggests, the goal of EMS systems is to carefully manage the energy expenditure of a building to reduce the total energy footprint and save money for the operator. Before EMS systems entered the foodservice world, these products were popularized by effectively saving energy by managing the HVAC and lighting systems for office buildings. Simple programs that would turn down the lights and air conditioning systems when the building was unoccupied were successful in significantly reducing energy bills. More recently, EMS vendors have been targeting restaurants because of the large energy saving opportunities of these facilities. Unfortunately, the intricacies of energy management in the restaurant space have made it difficult for EMS to gain widespread popularity. With climbing energy costs and monthly energy bills upward of $5,000 for a single restaurant, energy management is beginning to make a great deal of sense.

We at the FSTC are dreaming about what the EMS of the future will look like. One day, restaurant operators will be able to view and control the energy consumption of nearly all of their energy using systems, from fryers to freezers, from hot plates to HVAC systems. Allowing operators to control these systems will allow energy usage to be optimized in ways never previously realized. These are the areas we hope the EMS of the future to touch on:

– HVAC
– Lighting
– Refrigeration
– Ice Machines
– Demand Control Ventilation
– Kitchen Appliances
– Water Heating

By opening an application, you, the restaurant operator, will be able to see real-time charts and graphs depicting where your energy is being used and how you can save money. You can already do this with many systems on the market today with your HVAC and lighting systems. Ultimately, we hope that all of your energy systems will be under this EMS umbrella, saving the most green possible!

Knowledge is Power: Kiana’s Gift

Richard Young, Senior Engineer and Director of Education

bio pic 020208b smallerLast week, the FSTC said goodbye to our gifted intern and social media specialist, Kiana Caban as she headed back to college for her senior year. Kiana will still help us with our Facebook and Linkdin pages throughout the year but, her real focus now will be graduating with top marks and a winning basketball season.

Before she left, Kiana finished one final project that just might be the most useful resource she could have created for the foodservice energy-efficiency community. Working with our webmaster, Greg Sorensen, she put together a master ENERGY STAR web page that organizes all the ENERGY STAR resources and knowledge base into one location. Here is the link so you can check it out for yourself: http://www.fishnick.com/saveenergy/energystar/.

You can also access this page by going to the FSTC homepage, clicking on the “Save Energy” menu at the top of the page and choosing “ENERGY STAR”.

The beauty of Kiana’s ENERGY STAR page is speed. She is a wicked good basketball player and when she is on the court, all she is thinking about is the shortest distance to the basket and quickly scoring another goal. Speed keeps you ahead of the competition. Kiana applied that same strategy to her resource page. If you need to find a piece of efficient equipment; or want to benchmark your energy use; or want to see if your efficient appliance qualifies for a rebate, the shortest distance to your goal is to use Kiana’s ENERGY STAR page. Got a story to share about efficiency in your own operation? Check out the “Share Your Story” link at the bottom of Kiana’s ENERGY STAR page.

Kiana Caban our gifted intern and social media specialist

Kiana Caban our gifted intern and social media specialist

There is no longer any reason to say that you cannot find an ENERGY STAR appliance or didn’t know that your ENERGY STAR equipment qualified for a utility incentive. Kiana has given you knowledge and knowledge is power – specifically, the power to lower your utility bills and save money.

One other project that Kiana worked on in her last few weeks was getting the FSTC more Facebook likes. Facebook is a quick and easy way for us to communicate the FSTC news, such as new reports, blog posts, seminars, etc., to our friends in the industry. One way that you could pay her back for creating the very useful ENERGY STAR page is to keep those likes coming. In fact, I have a very nice, state of the art LED lamp that I am going to send to one randomly chosen person out of the next 100 likes. So, don’t hesitate – here’s the link: https://www.facebook.com/fishnick.fstc

Finally, if you really want to do something nice for Kiana, you can root for her as she pushes the Oregon Tech women’s basketball team to victory this year (http://www.oit.edu/athletics/womens-basketball/schedule). Thanks Kiana. Go Owls!

Is there a Twinkie hanging from your ceiling? What your lighting might really be saying about your “sustainable” restaurant.

bio pic 020208b smallerRichard Young, Senior Engineer and Director of Education

People who have seen me speak at conferences, workshops and tradeshows are familiar with my technique of using humor to make a point about energy efficiency. I love nothing better than to poke a little fun at some of the energy-wasteful things that I see in the food service world – not to be bossy or pedantic – just to lighten the mood and perhaps illuminate some of the things that we might all be doing better. With that attitude in mind, I hope you will indulge me as we ponder the question of “the Twinkie hanging from your ceiling”.

But first, a little background: I love good food and I especially love good, locally-grown, freshly prepared food. In fact as I’m writing this I’m enjoying a cup of premium “third-wave” coffee and a vegetarian egg brioche with fresh figs, greens and walnuts on a gluten free bun. (This would be the appropriate time for my burger-and-fries friends to have a chuckle at my expense.) I’m sitting in a beautiful sunlit cafe in Oakland CA and right across the street I can see the super-popular, nationally-famous restaurant that first inspired the idea of these dangling twinkles that I want to talk about.

This restaurant is super-popular for a reason; the food is amazingly good, fresh, local, and creative and the chef/owner is completely dedicated to his craft. I’ve had some of my favorite meals here and it was in this restaurant, while I was having lunch with lighting expert Derry Berrigan, that I was first able to articulate what was bugging me so much about many of my favorite local restaurants and bars. Derry and I were talking about the current practice of using antique-looking Edison style lamps in so many new establishments. These lamps are not our favorites. Besides the fact that the last time these lamps were fashionable was back in the 90’s (that would be the 1890’s) they are incredibly inefficient light sources and they add lots of heat to the space. To a sustainability geek like myself, these are charming little eco-nightmares.

In a flash of insight it suddenly came to me: “Derry” I said, “this chef, who cares so much about food sustainability that he raises his own chickens, would never pull a Twinkie out of the package, throw it on a plate and add it to his desert menu, but his ceiling is filled with these antique space heaters masquerading as lighting. Seeing these lamps in a restaurant that prides itself on sustainability is just as weird as seeing a Twinkie on the menu.”

 twinkie

[Now don’t get me wrong. I love a Twinkie as much as the next guy. They are a much beloved snack food with an amazing shelf life. It’s just that they are not exactly farmer’s market fare.]

“Derry” I continued, “I think that if this chef and all his chef friends knew that these energy guzzlers were driving up their utility bills and wasting natural resources, they would find some alternative and this nostalgia fad would fade away.”

Derry, who is one of the Nation’s top LED experts and a forward thinking lighting designer, had a quick comeback. “Richard, you have to admit that these lamps do add a certain quaint charm to the space, especially in an old brick building like this. What’s your efficient alternative?”

Okay, point well taken. Derry always inspires me to think about the big picture. So here are a couple of thoughts regarding these lamps:

  1. If you really love the look of these lamps, please use them sparingly and think of them as “quaint decorations.” Then, make sure that you are using the most energy-efficient lighting in the rest of your business.
  2. Check out some of the efficient alternatives to these lamps. Manufacturers like Switch Lighting, Rambus, and Plumen make some lamps with really interesting form factors.
  3. Consider using actual fixtures instead of just lamps on a cord. When did we decide as a culture that bare bulbs hanging from the ceiling were “good design”? An LED lamp inside a nice pendant fixture is a better looking alternative and the energy savings will pay for the extra up-front cost of the fixture itself.

The bottom line is this: If you really want to operate a truly green and sustainable restaurant, then you should not be lighting your space with the most inefficient, energy-wasting light bulb on the planet. No Twinkies on the menu – no Twinkies hanging from the ceiling!

Changing Course: Energy Efficiency, LEED and the Institutional Kitchen

Richard Young, Senior Engineer and Director of Education

It has been a very busy summer at the FSTC. In the next few blog entries, we will share some of the places we’ve been and lessons learned starting with the Association of Correctional Foodservice Affiliates’ (ACFSA) International Conference in Reno. Because of the FSTC’s participation with the US Green Building Council and our work on the LEED criteria, the folks at ACFSA asked us to come to their conference and explain the basics of the LEED program to the correctional foodservice directors.

Very few correctional facilities, including correctional healthcare facilities, have had any experience with LEED, so the discussion in the morning seminar was fruitful and went well beyond the basics of green buildings and into the purchasing and specification of efficient equipment. A subject that was later continued in the afternoon Equipment-Experts panel led by Ira Kaplan of Irinox Industries.

Here are a few of the questions, answers, and insights:

One of the audience members shared how she was discouraged by her superiors from getting LEED AP certification. They told her that LEED would be “dead in three years”. She was relieved to hear that LEED is alive and well and not going away. We talked about the fact that the first version of LEED was initially created in 1998 – not very long ago for an international standard – and that the LEED criteria were still evolving. The new LEED Version 4, that just passed ballot, will be out soon and will be simpler and easier to use then previous versions. We also talked about the fact that many state and federal building programs are tying new-building funding to LEED-standard design and construction, meaning that LEED will not be fading away anytime soon.

Several audience members also related how difficult it is to get people engaged in bringing “sustainability” to the institutional kitchen – a point reiterated in the afternoon equipment panel.  In the morning seminar we had to agree that it is sometimes an insurmountable challenge to get “old minded” architects/engineers to change their institutionalized thinking and incorporate efficiency or new technologies into their kitchens. So, we focused on the money argument and cooked up an example, using the FSTC online calculators, where the high-efficiency oven saved almost $14,000 over the low-efficiency oven in its 12 year lifespan. We all agreed that saving money is probably the best way to influence decision makers in an institutional setting.

In the afternoon panel, the equipment experts made another really important point: food service directors have a lot more influence over design and policy than they realize and it is time to “flex that muscle” with everyone from architects to manufacturers.

Steve Welborn, Food Facilities Food Planning, pointed out how important it is to have a knowledgeable food service consultant working on the design and that it is just as important to have the food service director on the design/planning team.

Peter Cooper, Middleby Corporation, pointed out the power of knowledge and urged the foodservice directors to learn about their equipment, how it operates, and what it costs over its entire life cycle and both Ira Kaplan and John Horvath, Heritage Food Service Group, stressed the importance of finding the right service organization to take care of your equipment so you get the maximum lifespan.

Jim Beach, the current president of ACFSA, and a person with lots of experience building correctional kitchens, made a point that resonated loud and clear with everyone in the afternoon audience: “Most institutional food service directors will only oversee the creation of one kitchen in their lifetime so it’s important to learn about the equipment, demand the best, and stick to your guns.”

The equipment in institutional kitchens is expected to last a long, long time. Value engineering appliances to save a few bucks on the front end can cost you many times more in maintenance, performance and utility costs over the lifespan of that equipment.

 

FSTC presents at SCAA Annual Exposition in Boston

SCAA 25th expo

April 12-14th Richard Young attended and presented at the SCAA 25th Annual Expo in Boston. Richard co-presented with Meredith Taylor from SCAA and (in absentia) Kirstin Henninger a presentation titled “Creating a Sustainable Café with SCAA Tools: a How-To with Case Studies” (http://www.fishnick.com/handouts/04132013/).

Richard had a great time at the event and met with lots of key figures from the coffee industry. Attendees were very excited about the release of the Energy & Water Modules for the Green Guide

Your local cafe is getting greener…

Did you know that the FSTC has partnered with the Green Cafe Network and the Specialty Coffee Association of America to develop a comprehensive sustainability guide specifically for cafe and coffee shops?

green-guide-preview_Page_1The FSTC has contributed their technical expertise, key research and years of experience to create the Energy & Water Modules of the SCAA Green Guide. The Green Guide is a series of digital booklets, published in modules that will cover key strategies for cafe operators in energy conservation, waste reduction, water conservation, and toxics reduction. The goal is to link simple, practical steps with a broader industry effort. Module #1 offers structured guidance on how to reduce costs specific to lighting, refrigeration, appliances & HVAC.

green-guide-preview_Page_3

The Green Guide is part of SCAA’s Low Impact Cafe Program.The SCAA Low Impact Cafe Program is a new program designed for coffee retailers. The goal of the program is to provide tips on how to lower your cafe’s operating costs and overall environmental impact that are both easy to understand and implement. The program also includes tools of measurement so that every participating retailer has the ability to quantify their efforts both for business purposes as well as to directly communicate to their customers.

20000

There are two components of the program; the Green Guide and the START database. START is a powerful online database that allows retailers to input monthly utility use data related to their business and discover the impact of their sustainability efforts. The Green Guide provides a mechanism for measurement offered through START and a recognition vehicle for participating cafes.

start-logo

The Low Impact Cafe program was designed with the cafe and coffee retailer in mind, and built to make sustainability at the cafe achievable!

landing-pageWe are currently working hard on the Water Module and it will be ready for the public early this summer! In the meantime, attend the 25th Annual SCAA Exposition on April 13th to hear Richard Young present on the Green Guide and give you key tips to energy conservation in your cafe!

———————————————————————–
Our Partners:

SCAA

SCAA-logo2The Specialty Coffee Association of America (SCAA) is the world’s coffee authority and largest coffee trade association with nearly 5,000 members including member companies and their employees. SCAA members are located in more than 40 countries and represent every segment of the specialty coffee industry, including producers, roasters, importers/exporters, retailers, manufacturers, baristas and coffee enthusiasts. SCAA is dedicated to creating a vibrant specialty coffee community, recognizing, developing and promoting specialty coffee by setting and maintaining quality standards for the industry; conducting research on coffee, equipment and perfection of craft; and providing education, training, resources and business services for its members.

 

Green Cafe Network

Green Cafe Ngreenetwork’s mission is make sustainability mainstream by greening the coffeehouse industry. In addition to their sustainability consulting and education services, GCN has built a growing network of member cafes across the United States that are committed to running green businesses.

Introducing Elan!

The FSTC is proud to introduce our newest and youngest (at just 23 years) engineer on the team: Elan Frantz. Elan is a recent graduate from the University of California, at Santa Barbara, where he holds a B.S. in Mechanical Engineering. Though Elan may be new to our lab, he’s no stranger to efficiency.

While a student at UCSB, Elan led an intern project that used thermoelectric (TE) devices to capture waste heat from central processing units (CPUs) and to generate power. He successfully built physical models that proved TE devices can be utilized to lower the temperature of the CPU using thermal absorption and by powering a fan. You can learn more about this project here.

Elan and Big Belly

Elan tackled many advanced projects through his department and single-handedly spearheaded a major campus-wide effort to improve the efficiency of the recycling/compost/waste-streams. He also gave the Class of 2012 Commencement Speech at graduation for the UCSB Science and Engineering Department!

Elan commencement speech

Below is an interview Lauren Mills conducted with Elan to celebrate National Engineers Week  (February of 2013).
———————————————————————————————-

Lauren Mills: Can you tell me a bit more about some of the projects you were responsible for at UCSB?

Elan Frantz: Well the big one was a waste streamlining effort I called “The Big Belly Project”. When I got to college freshman year we were presented with the challenge to write about improving some aspect of the campus. The first things that popped into my head were, like, solar-powered spaceships, rocket cars…all this stuff…and then, I had this idea to compact trash so that the garbage trucks don’t have to come as often. It turns out someone already does this, it’s a company called Big Belly out of Massachusetts, and they do it very well.

So, I worked over the next 4 years to try to refit the entire UCSB system with these trash bins. And on the day of my graduation, I got funding to do it. Now there are 18 Big Belly waste units on the campus and we are diverting tons of trash every day.

Mills: What bins are included with the units?

Frantz: There is recycling, trash, and one of the first compacting compost programs in the US, well, in the world. You can look at it from a couple of different angles: first of all, since we are compacting things, people aren’t going there as often. What were 14 trips a week for some facilities management people has turned into 2 trips a week. In the face of huge budget cuts, that gives these departments the resources to keep the campus clean, collect the trash that needs to be collected, and maintain the grounds. So it’s been a real blessing for them.

Also, because the bins trap the trash and lock it in, the contents cannot escape to the local ocean areas or even around the campus. Before, we had a big problem with raccoons diving into the trash cans and just tearing everything out. Even seagulls would get into it. As simple as it is, the Big Bellys are a closed system and they don’t let that happen.

Mills: Very cool…so risks of inadvertently polluting the surrounding areas are reduced and no more litter problem!

Frantz: The other cool thing is just the appearance of it. Everything is very clearly labeled and color coded: Yellow is compost, blue is recycling, black is trash.

Mills: So, it looks like from your history at the University you have a clear interest in not just energy efficiency and the efficiency of mechanical systems, but in sustainability and engineering sustainable solutions.

Frantz: Oh, most definitely.

Mills: Switching gears, can you tell us about what you are starting to work on here at the FSTC? Also, maybe what you would like to investigate and research in the future here?

Frantz: Of course. What I didn’t know when I came here, is that, if somebody wanted to make an energy efficient kitchen 25 years ago, they wouldn’t have the resources to do it. So the part I now play in this is the testing of the equipment.

Mills: What is your official title at the FSTC?

Frantz: Research Engineer. So, I try to set up real world kitchen situations in our lab to test the heavy-use efficiency of appliances. When someone is choosing a convection oven, an exhaust hood, a stovetop range, they are going to have a lot of options. I compare those options for them and present to them useful data that will hopefully help them select the most efficient option, with which they can also maintain a functional kitchen.

Elan and Fryer Challenge

Mills: Is this your first time working with ASTM test methods?

Frantz: Yes it is.

Mills: What appliances have you worked with here and applied the ASTM test methods to?

Frantz: Holding cabinets, a wok, a griddle, a fryer, some combis and convection ovens.

Mills: Did any one of them employ any interesting components or technologies that made them more efficient than your average unit?

Frantz: Yes! The wok pan employed some proprietary features that were pretty interesting. A normal wok pan may be only 10% efficient and the new wok pan, with these unique improvements, was tested to be 15% efficient. So it’s improved by 50%. With a 50% efficiency gain you can actually turn your temperature controls down to 2/3 of the original input.

I’ve also tested and reported on a wok range that was designed to reduce water consumption (needed for cooling the equipment) by featuring an air gap between the burner wells and the wok table surface.

Mills: Besides testing and getting familiar with the ASTM test methods, are you working on anything else at the lab?

Frantz: Well, I’m involved with the Green Team.

Mills: Tell me about that.

Frantz: Basically, the waste streams at the FSTC are really efficient. Most of the time there is no reason to throw anything in the waste stream because the majority of things here can be composted or recycled. In addition the appliances we use in house, like our lights and heating, are also efficient. The Green Team looks over all of that.

Mills: Do you have plans for applying some of your past experiences and interests to come up with some new protocols for the Green Team?

Frantz: Totally. Perhaps my first efforts will be looking into miniature ozone-generators to eliminate odors in the compost bins. I do have several ideas that I want to contribute this year and I’m excited to get start.

Mills: Great, well we are really glad to have you join our team at the FSTC and I look forward to future collaborations with you at the lab.

———————————————————————————————-

Every day at the FSTC our staff is working towards a more energy efficient and sustainable future. Read our blog and also visit our Facebook page to stay up to date with our growing rebate programs, in-lab testing, and our in-house green business efforts.

We look forward to additional testing on efficient wok ranges and will be providing updates as we collect more data. An appliance test report is available for the water-efficient wok that Elan tested on our website.

 

FSTC guest educational offerings at PowerSave Green Campus Summit and the PG&E Pacific Energy Center (PEC)

Link

Hedrick Dining Hall at UCLAFSTC Research Engineer, Kong Sham, teaches students from the student-led statewide energy-efficiency program, PowerSave Green Campus, how to perform a comprehensive energy and water audit at their UCLA campus dining hall. For several years the FSTC has partnered with the Alliance to Save Energy and their PowerSave Green Campus program, to present hands-on and classroom based educational sessions for the students of the program, which currently represent over 100 students at 23 UCs and CSUs across the state. This particular session took place at the 9th Annual 2013 PowerSave Green Campus Energy Efficiency Summit.Kong and students

Learn more about the PowerSave program here.

The Annual Summits give new and experienced PowerSave Green Campus interns the opportunity to attend training sessions on project planning, learn about best practice projects and technologies that have been successful at a number of campuses, and network with professional who have made a career in the energy field.

Kong demonstrating energy & water efficiency fundamentals

Here, Kong is demonstrating some advanced LED technologies for MR-16 applications that would work well in the dining hall serving areas and foodservice retail locations on campus – looking great while reducing electric use of the fixtures significantly. These MR16 LEDs are meant to replace halogen lamps and will save about 75% of the energy consumed per watt.

Kong gives LED lighting demo to students

Speaking of lighting and unique educational opportunities, have you seen the latest video on our Video Corner? It depicts the superb lighting class the FSTC recently hosted at PG&E’s Pacific Energy Center in San Francisco, CA.

Check out the Advanced Lighting Seminar video here.

 

Ever wonder what ASTM Standard Test Method development looks like?

 Meat before test Meat testing in Cook & Hold Our fellow research technicians down at Southern California Edison’s (SCE) Foodservice Technology Center (FTC) just sent us these appetizing photos of their latest test method development efforts for the Cook & Hold equipment category (ASTM F26.06). A draft of this Standard Test Method (STM) has been submitted to the ASTM committee for ballot and we think that they will have no beef with the procedures!Meat after test